Peña’s Fall From Grace: Presidential Impeachment in Paraguay

Three years into his presidential term, Santiago Peña has now been impeached and remains under house arrest for his involvement in Paraguay’s worst political crisis in over a decade. Until last year he was a chief stakeholder in Ueno, a digital bank supported by public funds that collapsed the first week of November due to imprudent lending practices which temporarily blocked almost 3 out of the 6.5 million population’s access to their savings. The Central Bank head and Ueno ex-president, Carlos Carvallo, appointed by Peña, has also stepped down and faces criminal charges. 

On November 5th, Peña attempted to hand in his resignation letter, which the Senate rejected in a resounding rebuke. The following day all 44 senators present voted to impeach the former president, revoking his immunity from prosecution and initiating a pretrial arrest for charges of breach of trust and administration for personal gain. He is succeeded by Vice President Pedro Alliana, who also faced an impeachment motion, regarding complicity in the banking scandal, that ultimately failed. 

Up until recently, Peña maintained a relatively steady administration in comparison to other leaders and implemented several successful reforms to expand economic growth during his tenure. Ueno, which launched in 2021, played a significant role in shaping Paraguay’s current financial system, granting millions of citizens access to a bank account for the first time and becoming one of the nation’s largest lenders. However, this recent turn of events pulls the curtain back on the country’s institutional precarity and political divisions. 

Peña’s fall from grace displays the control Colorado Party leader and past president Horacio Cartes wields over Paraguay’s political sphere. While in office, Cartes chose Santiago Peña as finance minister and endorsed his presidential bid. Although he works behind the scenes, Cartes is known for still pulling the political strings. 

Despite Cartes’s patronage, Peña distanced himself from this longtime mentor, with his own history of corruption, and attempted to build his own power base that hinged upon Ueno’s prominence. These fissures in the Colorado Party fed tendencies of crony capitalism that kept Ueno afloat. Santiago Peña abused his authority to exceed public funding limits and evade regulatory scrutiny of a risky business venture. 

With the help of Cartes, this scheme backfired tremendously. Peña already faced pressure from party factions in the legislature for his ties to Ueno. However, in September the situation escalated after many of Cartes’s allies in the Senate began to question the Central Bank publicly about Ueno’s stability. These probes gained traction in following weeks, resulting in the Central Bank’s decision to seize the digital lender. The credibility of Santiago Pena’s administration and Ueno were intertwined. When scandal erupted, the president could not escape the subsequent political shrapnel that unseated him. 

Although Peña’s impeachment represents a step toward government accountability, the motivations for this act of justice demonstrate an appetite for score-settling rather than commitment to institutional transparency. As Paraguay recovers from new economic straits, it is important that the nation continues interrogating the underlying conditions that produced such a crisis in the first place. 

Next
Next

Putting Political Tensions Aside in Kraków